Bolshevik Uprising in Kiev

scook17 · 06-10-2008, 01:30 AM

Opinions on this badge please.

The same seller was selling this one, which desantnik has said he 'didn't like'.

http://www.soviet-awards.com/forum/s...man-badge.html

Kind Regards,
Shane Cook.

scook17 · 06-10-2008, 01:32 AM

Some more photos.

scook17 · 06-10-2008, 01:33 AM

And the last set

***desantnik*** · 06-10-2008, 06:37 AM

Shane, I don't like this one either.

For this I'm going off of memory, but have seen 3-4 actuals several years ago of this piece. The current butch of forgers is capitalizing on great demand and many collectors who don't know "what right looks like".

There are many excellent fakes of these early badges coming out. From Georgia, I've seen several that were fake early aviation badges, deputy badges, etc.. The enamel on both these pieces is too cherry red and too glassy for being 70+ years old. There seem to be no nicks, scratches, and day-to-day wear that is evident on real pieces. Additionally, on the other badge the enamel was too white and my alarm goes off when I see the "mickey mouse ear" screwback. I don't remember the reverse screwback being this elaborate either - this is one that I would have remembered. If one dealer has both of these pieces (and/or more) I'd be even more wary.

***desantnik*** · 06-10-2008, 07:41 AM

Is this one or two pieces? There is a rather large, artificial enamel break on the 2/3 o'clock ray on one and none on the other.

Enamel does not break like this.

Eryk · 06-10-2008, 09:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by desantnik

Is this one or two pieces?

It must be two different pieces. Didn't even notice at first.

It's like one of those "spot the difference" cartoons. :chuckle

Lapa · 06-10-2008, 09:40 AM

Shane,

Stay away :thumbsdown

This badge simply doesn't have that 1920's feel that the real badges have. Paul pointed out at the enamel, I'll add the glaring lack of details.

It is also quite disturbing that the seller is showing 2 clearly different badges. These are simply so rare, that to own one would be an achievement, and to own two would be simply out of this world (OK guys, prove me wrong; someone on this forum must have a couple of those - I mean genuine ones, of course :D)

Marc

scook17 · 06-10-2008, 01:56 PM

This one badge, not two, or at least being sold that way. I have a number of other photos of badges from the same seller. I will post them later. Thanks guys.

Kind Regards,
Shane Cook.

Lapa · 06-10-2008, 03:01 PM

Shane,

On the pictures that you posted, there are clearly 2 different badges: one which is similar to what it purports to be, and the second one with the missing enamel and which also has the lower right side of the cogwheel missing. The seller may claim that he is showing one badge, you should clearly know better.

Given this seller's track record, I am not sure you really need to keep bothering with his offerings, IMHO.

Marc

scook17 · 06-10-2008, 04:26 PM

Here is another one of the sellers badges.

06-10-2008, 06:37 AM	#4
*desantnik* Forum Moderator Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: Eurasia Posts: 2,339	Re: Bolshevik Uprising in Kiev Shane, I don't like this one either. For this I'm going off of memory, but have seen 3-4 actuals several years ago of this piece. The current butch of forgers is capitalizing on great demand and many collectors who don't know "what right looks like". There are many excellent fakes of these early badges coming out. From Georgia, I've seen several that were fake early aviation badges, deputy badges, etc.. The enamel on both these pieces is too cherry red and too glassy for being 70+ years old. There seem to be no nicks, scratches, and day-to-day wear that is evident on real pieces. Additionally, on the other badge the enamel was too white and my alarm goes off when I see the "mickey mouse ear" screwback. I don't remember the reverse screwback being this elaborate either - this is one that I would have remembered. If one dealer has both of these pieces (and/or more) I'd be even more wary.

06-10-2008, 07:41 AM	#5
*desantnik* Forum Moderator Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: Eurasia Posts: 2,339	Re: Bolshevik Uprising in Kiev Is this one or two pieces? There is a rather large, artificial enamel break on the 2/3 o'clock ray on one and none on the other. Enamel does not break like this.

06-10-2008, 09:40 AM	#7
Lapa Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: St Petersburg, Russia Age: 63 Posts: 2,397	Re: Bolshevik Uprising in Kiev Shane, Stay away :thumbsdown This badge simply doesn't have that 1920's feel that the real badges have. Paul pointed out at the enamel, I'll add the glaring lack of details. It is also quite disturbing that the seller is showing 2 clearly different badges. These are simply so rare, that to own one would be an achievement, and to own two would be simply out of this world (OK guys, prove me wrong; someone on this forum must have a couple of those - I mean genuine ones, of course :D) Marc

06-10-2008, 01:56 PM	#8
scook17 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2002 Location: United Kingdom Posts: 220	Re: Bolshevik Uprising in Kiev This one badge, not two, or at least being sold that way. I have a number of other photos of badges from the same seller. I will post them later. Thanks guys. Kind Regards, Shane Cook.

06-10-2008, 03:01 PM	#9
Lapa Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: St Petersburg, Russia Age: 63 Posts: 2,397	Re: Bolshevik Uprising in Kiev Shane, On the pictures that you posted, there are clearly 2 different badges: one which is similar to what it purports to be, and the second one with the missing enamel and which also has the lower right side of the cogwheel missing. The seller may claim that he is showing one badge, you should clearly know better. Given this seller's track record, I am not sure you really need to keep bothering with his offerings, IMHO. Marc

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Greater Poland Cross Of Insurgency.	Taz	Polish Medals	3	09-02-2007 04:04 PM
Warsaw Cross Of Insurgency.	Taz	Polish Medals	0	09-01-2007 03:57 AM
Silesian Cross Of Insurgency.	Taz	Polish Medals	4	04-05-2006 06:43 PM
The Bolshevik poster	Tal Inbar	History References	0	03-11-2002 07:48 AM