+- The Soviet Military Awards Page Forum (https://soviet-awards.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Soviet Awards Forums (https://soviet-awards.com/forum/Forum-Soviet-Awards-Forums)
+--- Forum: Union Of Soviet Socialist Republics (https://soviet-awards.com/forum/Forum-Union-Of-Soviet-Socialist-Republics)
+---- Forum: Fake Alert! (https://soviet-awards.com/forum/Forum-Fake-Alert)
+----- Forum: Fake Badges (https://soviet-awards.com/forum/Forum-Fake-Badges)
+----- Thread: Fake KGB Badge (/Thread-Fake-KGB-Badge)
Pages:
1
2
Fake KGB Badge - DougD - 03-09-2008
This badge was part of a very large and well established state-security collection that was recently sold off...this was the only badge that was not easy to ID (if its ok).
Thoughts?
DougD
Fake KGB Badge - desantnik - 03-09-2008
Everything about it looks crapola - irregular white enamel, "neon" colors, too darkened bronze colors, etc.
Fake KGB Badge - DougD - 03-09-2008
That was the fear...if bad, what badge were they trying to copy?
Fake KGB Badge - Kirchgoens - 03-09-2008
The white enamel doesn't look much worse than what I've seen on some early guard badges, some of the paramilitary badges, and labor badges from the 40's and earlier. In short, it generally doesn't look that bad to me.
I think better lighting and macro on the photos might tell a bit more. Beyond that, I don't know my chekist badges, so I'm starting from a delightful point of ignorance.
Fake KGB Badge - Kirchgoens - 03-09-2008
On page 81 of Martin Goodman's "Lenin's Legacy", you'll find an 80's era "Honored Member of the KBG" badge that has the same layout, colors, and wording minus the white enamel, but the Goodman photo looks like an aluminum badge and has a goldish finish to the "bare" metal parts. Other than that, they are the same badge. The one in the photo in the posting above just looks a lot older and with white enamel.
Fake KGB Badge - Lapa - 03-09-2008
Doug,
How about showing us 'the dark side of the moon'.
Marc
Fake KGB Badge - DougD - 03-09-2008
Here is the back of the badge; seems very dark, was tough to get much detail.
DougD
Fake KGB Badge - Lapa - 03-09-2008
Doug,
The back confirms what we thought: fake patina, not of MD manufacture...
Marc
Fake KGB Badge - Aharim - 03-10-2008
I am not good on these, and all info from here is hearsay, but a "friend" once told me, "green backround is border guard," for what its worth. They were a part of the organs and there is a Russia web site with a green background "egg."
Fake KGB Badge - Aharim - 03-10-2008
THe above relates to what it was "supposed" to be.