The Soviet Military Awards Page Forum  
  • Serial Numbers Database 2.0
Enter Here

vBClassified Featured Listings
Opanasyuk Socialist Comp
Kutsak Socialist Comp
Echoes of War
VoG Patsyuk
Shevchenko Labor Valor

Go Back   The Soviet Military Awards Page Forum > Soviet Awards Forums > Union Of Soviet Socialist Republics > Soviet Medals > Researched Soviet Medals > Researched Medals Of Ushakov

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 05-29-2010, 12:36 AM   #11
desantnik
Forum Moderator
 
desantnik's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Eurasia
Posts: 2,163
Re: Ushakov medal in Penal Battalion

Eryk,

Splendid blog. I enjoyed seeing your pieces, but more enjoyed your commentary on the state of the market, "friendly" collector community, CSM vs MMM, etc. :thumbsup

I disagree with your assertion:

"Prisoners in the penal battalions/companies were indeed awarded medals and orders. They were still military personnel..."

Admittedly the onus of evidence is on me since we're actually looking at two pieces associated with penal/disciplinary units (the Ushakov in this thread and your BM), but I'm fairly certain more than one Russian source has stated that those serving in a penal unit weren't really considered "soldiers" and were thus ineligible for awards. Bad on me for not referencing the source at the time and presently I'm overseas so I won't have ready access to my research material for some time.

We have to remember the mentality of 1930 Soviet Union with enemies of the state, cult of personality, GULAGs, surrender = traitor, etc. to understand the horrific nature of penal units. Just the fact that the person sentenced to such a unit was stripped of his rank and sent to an almost certain death sentence unless surviving his term and/or being wounded, does not lend itself to its recipients being "worthy" of receiving a State award. A simple reading of the period's award booklets mentioning that the recipient must maintain high standards, be an example of an outstanding citizen, etc. or face having the award revoked shows that receiving an award was a big deal. Such a momentous event does not readily lend itself to disgraced members of a unit trying to reprove their loyalty to the State.

We've all seen unit award listings in which many of the recipients received decorations just for "being there". A penal unit's presence or participation in a battle was by design, in the very thick of things so if eligible, I would propose we'd see even more penal unit member awardings which we don't. Again, I don't have access to the source, but I have an article that talked specifically about penal units and at any one time there were something like several divisions worth of soldiers/sailors in penal units (not in organic units, but sprinkled through the force). This is credible since the Soviet Army fielded over 300 rifle divisions. Frequency-wise I've seen more awards to the special operations OMSBON brigade, then we've seen awarded to penal units in the aggregate. I think the rarity of penal unit awardings speaks for itself.

That being said, this emphasizes the rarity of these two particular pieces. Again, I think they were awarded to either "non-penal" command and control element such as the commander award I mentioned and to support him, he would have needed lower enlisted to carry radios, do paper work, etc. The other possibility is as mentioned, these awards were administrative or valor exceptions or oversights.

Can you send me the digital research of your BM award citation to see if there are any other clues?

Any one else got an idea?
desantnik is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Old 05-29-2010, 02:10 AM   #12
deValcourt
Senior Member
 
deValcourt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Cajun Country
Age: 53
Posts: 1,565
Re: Ushakov medal in Penal Battalion

From a psychological standpoint, I am looking at a dilemma over the motivations of those who found themselves part of a penal unit. On the one hand, it would seem logical that some of the men who were trying to redeem themselves during Stalin's purges would go out of their way to be "heroic" and charge up the hill when no one else would. This would attract the attention of the leaders of such groups and they could (at least hope to) find themselves "rehabilitated" and given some sort of award to cement that new state of mind.

On the other hand, it seems more likely that the men serving in these units would be rather demoralized from the start and may have taken foolish risks in order to either be wounded or killed. Either way, they would escape their current fate - especially with the latter option. Still, this would be a fighting unit that could be heroic or simply useful as canon fodder, depending on who was giving the orders and how high up the chain of command he was. I don't see anyone being awarded anything from a group with a majority of its soldiers feeling this "escape or die trying" attitude.

But there is also a third possibility. The entire unit is utterly hopeless in their own eyes and would go through the motions and reluctantly follow orders, but with no designs on heroics, only surviving the length of their sentence.

In reality, I imagine a penal unit was made up of all three types and anyone leading a group of men like this who was worth his salt would certainly deserve an award if he could manage to get a coordinated effort out of his men that produced results on the battlefield.

Just thoughts.:)

Phillip
__________________
Phillip
deValcourt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-17-2014, 03:40 PM   #13
CtahhR
Forum Administrator
 
CtahhR's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Deep In The Archives.
Age: 14
Posts: 11,957
Re: Ushakov,03514,Submachinegunner,487th Independent Disciplinary Battalion

Here is the original citation.
Attached Images
File Type: jpg ivaa.jpg (117.6 KB, 3 views)
File Type: jpg ivab.jpg (121.1 KB, 0 views)
__________________
"Signed with his own rubber stamp"
CtahhR is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are Off
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Glory III,485070,Lead Scout,487th Separate Scout Company,218th Rifle Division CtahhR Researched Orders Of Glory 5 11-15-2015 03:30 PM
Ushakov,04534,Senior Sailor,Separate Brigade Of Patrol Ships Of Border Troops marsino Researched Medals Of Ushakov 20 08-12-2014 05:16 AM
Lenin,009487,Trackman,37th Separate Reconstruction Railway Battalion Nota Bene Researched Orders Of Lenin 2 01-21-2014 04:00 PM
Red Star,0124040,Commander,6th Separate Vehicle Battalion Bill Garvy Researched Orders Of The Red Star 4 12-18-2010 12:26 PM

VTG Ww2-Vietnam M-1945 SLEEPING BAG COVERs WATER RESistant New & Used Lot Of 320
$10000.0
VTG Ww2-Vietnam M-1945 SLEEPING BAG COVERs WATER RESistant New & Used Lot Of 320 picture1946 parachute along without bag
$8500.0
1946 parachute along without bag picture1946 UNUSED 24' SILK PARACHUTE + PILOT CHUTE Pioneer Parachute Co-NO CORDS/BAG
$8399.0
1946 UNUSED 24' SILK PARACHUTE + PILOT CHUTE Pioneer Parachute Co-NO CORDS/BAG pictureWWII 442ND MEDIC JAPANESE AMERICAN GO FOR BROKE BAG BOX MEDICINE PATCH MAP
$5000.0
WWII 442ND MEDIC JAPANESE AMERICAN GO FOR BROKE BAG BOX MEDICINE PATCH MAP pictureMILITARY HAZMAT SUIT , BOOTS , HELMET , BAGS , GAS MASK
$3203.88
MILITARY HAZMAT SUIT , BOOTS , HELMET , BAGS ,  GAS MASK picture



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:27 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ©2011 Arthur G. Bates III