Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Fake KGB and "Egg" Badges
Marc ,

Thanks for your valuable opinion , but it seems to me that other than absence of mint mark , the obverse (especially) and reverse details are completely the same. I heard that not all original of these supposed to have mint marks..
I am wondering if Alexei could express his opinion ?

Thanks a lot.
Paul
Reply
Paul,

If you compare closely your badge and the picture I posted, you'll see obvious differences, especially in the sharpness (or lack thereof) of details, the surface, and of course the chemical patina.

Sebastien,

Early mintmarks are faked. They tend to be much less detailed than the original ones; since they are incused, they do not wear much and retain most of their details.

Marc
Reply
Marc ,

Thanks again. Let's see what Alexei might say.
I am placing one more image with some more details.

Paul


Attached Files Image(s)
DSC09282.jpg
Reply
Marc ,

I just found the following samples of authentic badges w/out mint mark.
It seems to me that number '1' on badge with serial # 991 is written by the same hand as on badge in my first posting :).

Thanks a lot.
Paul


Attached Files Image(s)
1a.jpg 2b.jpg
Reply
Guys,

Much better scans are needed. I also need to see the right side of the obverse. Preliminary, I don't like it - it looks rather crude, especially the H&S and the sword; the serial number and the "No" are different, and it looks like they were done with a different engraving tool; rivets, patina, etc., etc. ... in other words .... what Marc said.

Alexei
Reply
Hello , sorry for delay. I got some additional image and also sample of original badge with similar # sign. I would appreciate any additional opinions.

Thanks a lot.
Paul


Attached Files Image(s)
img234.jpg DSC01040.jpg 420-1.jpg
Reply
Paul,

I have nothing to add. If you compare the writing style on ## 150 and 140 and the width of the lines, especially at the turns, you will see that they are different.

Alexei
Reply
Paul,

I'll stand with my previous opinion, and join Alexei :thumbsdown

Marc
Reply
I watched this sell and didnt bid, please tell me its a fake

I just expected it to be a fake and because I'm a newbie collector I didnt dare.


Attached Files Image(s)
ussr11.jpg ussr13.jpg ussr14.jpg ussr.jpg
Reply
NKVDawards Wrote:I watched this sell and didnt bid, please tell me its a fake

You made the right choice, it is a fake.

Alexei
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Militaria for sale on