Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Medal "For The Defence Of Stalingrad".
#21
I am considering to buy this award for the defense of stalingrad. Do you think it is original?
Thank you for your opinions.
cheers


Attached Files Image(s)
web3-defense-of-stalingrad-.jpg web1-defense-of-stalingrad-.jpg web2-defense-of-stalingrad-.jpg
Reply
#22
It's good. If you pay close attention, you'll notice an 812 RR stamp, but a 201 Gds RR notation, that's because the 812 was reflagged into the 201. Nice historical moment captured in the paperwork.
Reply
#23
Thank you Desantnik for your comment. I wouldn't have noticed that detail without your help. I am glad it is an original award.

Better scan of the Stalingrad award after having received it. The sheet was ripped in two pieces which have been put together with a sticky strip of paper on the back.
In addition, I notice the paper is quite thick and rigid. What I found suspicious is that there is no markings left on the paper by the typewritten characters near the stamp. The surface looks flat and smooth on both sides of the document. I tried to make good scans to help your assessment.
Thank you

ciao
sergio


Attached Files Image(s)
web-Stalingrad-doc-front-fu.jpg web-Stalingrad-doc-rearfu.jpg web-Stalingrad-doc-detail-s.jpg web-Stalingrad-doc-detail-j.jpg web-Stalingrad-doc-detail-n.jpg
Reply
#24
There is nothing wrong with the authenticity of this document.
Reply
#25
Hello,

what could be the reason of the damage to the Stalingrad medal.
The damage must be caused by something with very high energie. The damage on the reverse left signs on avers.
A bullet perhaps? or a shiver of an artillery shell?

best regards and thanks
Andreas


Attached Files Image(s)
Stalin damage r.jpg Stalin damage v.jpg
Reply
#26
It is one's personal choice, however, as for myself, all damaged awards to me are battleworn-whether on the battlefield or dropped in the kitchen. How do you know that a kid didn't damage it? For me, an award is an award despite the condition and all are special.:thumbsup
Reply
#27
From those images I'd lean more towards a die error at the mint. Andreas, can you post images of the full medal front and back please when you get the time?
"patina imparts character" - PJS
A wise man said: 'you should not pay a premium for what you want beyond your comfort level, and always ensure there is a mutually agreeable return policy.'
Reply
#28
Here is a full pictute of the medal.


Attached Files Image(s)
Stalingrad Medaille Var 1 vorne.JPG Stalingrad Medaille Var 1 hinten.JPG
Reply
#29
I have this old medal for the defense of Stalingrad in my collection, what do you think about the ribbon? is very curious ,strange.


Attached Files Image(s)
sta.JPG sta1.JPG
Only he is lost who gives himself up for lost.
Reply
#30
The ribbon seems to be good, with the red center line accentuated with pencil stripes!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)
Militaria for sale on