Very interesting. I just read in McDaniel's book that the medal was awarded to 'all servicemen and civilian volunteers in the Red Army, Navy, and NKVD who directly participated on the fronts of the Great Patriotic War or supporting the victory by their work in the military regions.' This takes in a large number of categories that were issued the award. It would be very interesting to see some post-war photos of foreign recipients wearing this award. It's too bad the ribbon wasn't with the medal, if there was one.
A better scan would've been helpfull. I am guessing that the patina is probably genuine, so the loop is most likely a repair. I have never seen a fake Victory medal yet.
Alexei
new world Wrote:Guys,
I've never seen this type of suspension ring on a Soviet medal. I doubt this this is fake, who would bother with such cheap medal?
Christophe Wrote:Could this medal been awarded to a foreigner (I mean non-Soviet, i.e. French or ...) and adapted to the "wear code" of the awardee to be consistent with his other medals ?
Just my thought...
Cheers.
Ch.
yes, indeeed, I 'd see it well in a french or more probably in a polish set (the great loop which hosts the ribbon)
Sebastien
"a spectre haunts Europe, the spectre of communism"
(a well-known german bearbed)
Christophe Wrote:Could this medal been awarded to a foreigner (I mean non-Soviet, i.e. French or ...) and adapted to the "wear code" of the awardee to be consistent with his other medals ?
Just my thought...
Cheers.
Ch.
Ch-
I concur with your idea. Or, perhaps it was made as a replacement for a foreigner who lost theirs.
William-
In regard to the Victory medal, since it is as cheap as it is, why not just buy it for a novelty if anything else. :D If you don't want to buy it, I will. ;)
Robert Pierce Wrote:Very interesting. I just read in McDaniel's book that the medal was awarded to 'all servicemen and civilian volunteers in the Red Army, Navy, and NKVD who directly participated on the fronts of the Great Patriotic War or supporting the victory by their work in the military regions.' This takes in a large number of categories that were issued the award. It would be very interesting to see some post-war photos of foreign recipients wearing this award. It's too bad the ribbon wasn't with the medal, if there was one.
Robert-
I actually have quite a few foreign groups with Victory medals in my collection. None of them that I own, however, have anything other than the "standard issue" Victory Over Germany medal.
In regard to the Victory medal, since it is as cheap as it is, why not just buy it for a novelty if anything else. :D If you don't want to buy it, I will. ;)
--Dave
Dave,
I'd buy the medal, but it's offered in Russia and I doubt the seller would through the trouble of sending such cheap medal to the US.
"Be civil to all, sociable to many, familiar with few, friend to one, enemy to none." Benjamin Franklin
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Member #193